Seedling Trays for Almost Free

So I have a beef with the folks who make those plastic seedling trays. Around here they cost a little over $5 each and they are about as flimsy as they could possibly be and yet survive the ride home to your place from the store.

They are so flimsy that they tend to crack and split even just washing them, let alone transporting one that's loaded with soil. 

So you're forced to buy two at a time and stack them. Now your seedling flats cost $10 each and even then, a fully loaded one is prone to splitting. 

If I were a cynical person I would tend to think this was all by design...

Since I have 500ft of growing beds to plant out in the spring, there is no way I'm prepared to bankroll one of these crappy manufacturers. There must be a better way I thought. And indeed there is.

Recall those awesome paper pot transplanters you can buy for the low price of $1,000? Well they use paper pots to start the seeds in. And got to wondering what the seedling stage of that system looks like.

As you can see, the paper pots themselves come in some sort of honeycomb configuration, and this sits in some special plastic tray.

Since I love the concept of taking a seedling in it's own pot and simply popping it into the garden just like the paper pot transplanter, I haven't had a lot of success with paper pots that I made out of newspaper.





Although the seedlings grew OK, they never really took off in the garden and I suspect it had something to do with the newspaper inhibiting root growth (because I dug them up later and had a look to find out why they weren't growing).


They were also a lot of work to make.

Then while I was studying the paper pot transplanter, it occurred to me that the people who invented this amazing device, probably got their inspiration from some sort of low tech system that existed before. But what could that be?

Then I realized that a low tech version of the paper pot transplanter flat looks a lot like a bunch of toilet paper rolls jammed together. Why I hadn't thought of toilet paper rolls before now is a mystery to me, but there they are already formed. And just like the paper pot transplanter pots, they are bottomless so root growth is unobstructed in the garden.

Now a toilet roll is about 4 inches long. But for most seedlings I only really need 2 inches of soil. I measured the depth of a commercial flat to confirm my assumption. So this means that every toilet paper roll produces two seedling pots if I cut it in half.

So I started hoarding toilet paper rolls through the winter. Cutting them in half, and folding them down to minimize the space they were taking up.

In the meantime I got to thinking about these annoying flats...

We do a decent amount of grocery shopping at No Frills, and as a result I need to break down the various cardboard boxes for recycling on a regular basis. 

One evening as I was doing this chore, I noticed that the boxes fruit gets shipped in are particularly difficult to break down because they are made of really sturdy stuff.

"Hey, these would make awesome seed raising flats if only they were waterproof" I thought to myself as I struggled to break them apart.

I put one aside anyway because I also realized that they fit my seed screening frames nicely and I have some grains to clean.

Later that week I went to screen the wheat and barley I had harvested in the fall and found that the cardboard flat did indeed work quite well in collecting all the chaff that my screens separated out from the seed. But the cardboard flat had holes in it through which some of the finer chaff would fall and make a mess on the floor.

To fix this, I grabbed a plastic garbage bag and placed the cardboard flat inside. Encased in this plastic film, the flat was now sealed and I could screen my small grains without making a mess all over the place.

It then occurred to me that this plastic encased cardboard flat was also waterproof, and would make an excellent seedling flat for the cost of a plastic bag!

Cardboard flat, toilet rolls, and a plastic bag. I don't think it could be more low-tech than that.

Permaculture Seed Raising Mix

This post is a follow on from my Thoughts on Growing Seedlings for Transplant. 

In this post, I'll talk about making my seed raising mix with the focus being on the life within this growing media as opposed to the typical focus on moisture and nutrients.

My partners in this exercise will be these guys. Composting worms.

Vermicompost, or worm castings are packed full of living organisms and organic exudates which absorb and regulate moisture within the soil. It also happens to be a nutrient dense medium which means that it's a perfect candidate for a base ingredient in a permaculture seed raising mix.

I already have a vermicomposting system, and a ready (and free) source of high quality vermicompost. I recommend you keep your own composting worms too. Not only are they low maintenance, but you have complete control over what goes in (and eventually comes out) of your system.

The first task in making this seed raising mix is to screen the finished vermicompost. It's loaded with seeds from melons, squash, apples, pears, and the odd banana sticker. So they all need to go.

I used a mesh trash can from the dollar store to do this and it worked incredibly well.

The next step is to assemble the ingredients:

• Screened Worm Castings
• Coconut Coir
• Perlite
• Vermiculite

I decided to use coconut coir as a replacement medium for peat because it's a renewable resource. It tends to have a few chunks and long fibers in there, but they can be picked out easily as you find them. The coconut coir acts as a binding agent and moisture absorbent.

The perlite adds a lot of microscopic surface area for the living organisms to colonize, and it also helps regulate moisture levels.

The vermiculite acts similarly to perlite, but it also introduces trace minerals into the mix. However vermiculite has better water holding capacity than perlite, while perlite has better aeration properties than vermiculite.

Finally, vermiculite is a much better buffering agent than perlite, and acts as a pH stabilizing influence in the mix.

The next step is to combine the ingredients:

• 4 Parts Worm Castings
• 2 Parts Coconut Coir
• 1 Part Perlite
• 1 Part Vermiculite

I was initially taken aback by the cost of the coconut coir. But when I went to measure it out, I found that is comes highly compressed, and it expands a lot so you need a lot less than you think you do.

I chose the ratios printed here for a number of reasons. Typical seed raising mixes that incorporate vermicompost use a lot less of it. However, these mixes are based on traditional paradigms which focus on sterility, air, water, and nutrients. This mix focuses on soil life.

I noticed while doing research online that there are a lot of mixed signals regarding worm castings. A lot of it has to do with people incorrectly assuming that because it looks like soil, it can be treated like soil. This is not the case at all. It absorbs a lot of water. It is incredibly sticky (from the bio-exudates), gooey, and unless you have worms actively turning and aerating it, it will set like concrete.

During my research, I stumbled across this article on growjourney:

How to Make Your Own DIY Seed Starting Mix For Garden Seeds

A lot of what they were advocating fell in line with my objectives, so I stole their recipe. Thanks guys!

The final step involves mixing it all together. You can see coconut coir chunks in there still, but overall it looks pretty much like the usual seed raising mix you buy, if a little heavy on the perlite by comparison.

Overall, I am optimistic for my seedlings. I know exactly what's in this mix, and because I make the worm castings for free, this will probably work out cheaper than buying high quality commercial product.

Thoughts on Growing Seedlings for Transplant

This year I am experimenting with a growing system that departs from my ongoing efforts with direct seeded crops, and this means that germinating seeds indoors and transplanting them out in the spring.

This got me thinking about how a permaculturist would approach this exercise considering that the typical gardener takes a sterile seed raising mix, puts it into one-shot plastic seed raising formers / trays, and plants their seeds into this.

This is all in an effort to avoid mold and a condition called "damping off" where young healthy seedlings all of a suddenly keel over and die.

But here's the thing. These seed raising mixes contain a lot of peat which as you hopefully already know is not a renewable resource. They essentially strip mine these deposits with machines that look like giant vacuum cleaners. Peat is also acidic.

Commercial seed raising mix also contains "special ingredients" that the manufacturer puts in to make their product better than the others. And since "special ingredients" often tends to be described as toxic gick depending on your point of view, I chose to make my own permaculture seed raising mix this year. 

Since I am also lazy and tight, I decided to not buy these plastic seed trays to raise my seeds. I found that they always split (by design?) and even though theoretically you can reuse them, in reality this isn't the case.

Pulling the seedlings out of these trays and 
gently placing them into the garden beds seems like a lot of tedious w-w-work to me too.

So what is a permaculture seed raising mix then and how is it different from the stuff you buy at Canadian Tire?

Well for starters, a sterile environment is really the antithesis of what permaculture is all about. I strongly suspect that the reason seed raising mix is sterilized is because the pre-sterilized mix is biologically so far out of balance that the cheapest and easiest way to address this is to nuke it.

Shouldn't plants be born into a rich ecosystem containing fungi, bacteria, and all sorts of living things we haven't even classified yet? Since stability arises out of complexity within natural systems, shouldn't we be seeking to make our seed raising mix as far from sterile as is humanly possible? Is it possible that the issues gardeners experience in raising seedlings comes from their growing media not being complex enough?

Perennial Forage Crops for the North

Perennial Forage Crops for the North

It is not widely known that the cattle we are familiar with in our part of the world originated in the forests and swamps of Northern Europe.

During the warm summer months, they would spend their time in the swamps, keeping cool, and grazing on the grasses and aquatic plants, much in the same way as moose do here in these parts today.

When winter descended, the cattle would move into the sheltered forests and survive through the winter by foraging on the undergrowth, and lower branches of trees.

Tree hay is a term used for the practice of pruning trees in July, when nutrients are high, and stored until winter when it is fed to livestock. 

The animals strip the leaves, tips, and bark from the tree hay and it provides a mineral rich alternative to standard hay made from grasses.

 Notice in this video that they are using standard coppice tree species, which means that the tree will grow back vigorously. A multi-functional aspect of this technique is that the animals process the wood so that the end product is suitable as fuel for a rocket mass heater.

Pines (so long as you don't plan on butchering the animal shortly after as it imparts an unpleasant flavour), Alder, Poplar (except black poplar), Silver Birch, Linden, willow, mulberry, elder.

Gorse has historically been used as a highly nutritious animal fodder which is preferred by livestock. It is cut right to the ground once every 2 years, with the top of the plant used for fodder, and the rest for animal bedding and fire wood. 

Be aware that wilted maple and cherry leaves contain toxins that are harmful to animals, however fresh and dried are fine.